TITLE: Only With Your Love
AUTHOR: Lisa Kleypas
PUBLICATION: Avon, February 1992
GENRE: Historical Romance – Pirates!
RATING: <3 <3 <3
I considered entitling this post “In which I discover an Old Skool Romance that I actually liked.” A few pages in, I thought to myself, “Oh NOOOoooos! This can’t be Lisa Kleypas!” but I continued reading…and continued reading…and read right to the end in one sitting. I quite enjoyed it. This book has every romance trope you can think of: Purple prose! Virgin widows! Forced Seduction! Honorable pirates! Mistaken identity! Irritating nicknames! Anachronistic sensibilities! But somehow, despite it all, I fell for the characters and was swept away by the adventure.
***Ahoy Spoilers!***
PLOT:
Celia Vallerand, 24-year-old french former-spinster, is on her honeymoon, on a ship bound for her husband’s family in New Orleans. Shy girl that she is, she has begged her husband to delay consummating the union until they know each other better. His seduction plans are interrupted when the ship is attacked by pirates. Everyone is killed except Celia, who is kidnapped as a prize for the eeevil pirate captain’s brother. Brought to the secret pirate island, she pleads for help from a rival pirate captain (ahoy hero!) who fights a duel for her and wins. They flee for their lives from eevil pirate captain #1.
The hero wears a scraggly full beard and long hair to hide his appearance (yuck). He has his own secret agenda for rescuing Celia, but he is attracted to her, despite her skinniness, boyish hips, and childlike face. He is still and evil pirate, despite being the hero, and plunders her treasure, inspiring hitherto unknown feelings of desire from her. He is shocked and angry to discover that her bounty had never been stolen before (hehheh). Celia is, understandably, upset.
Arriving in New Orleans at the Vallerand family plantation, Celia is dismayed to find that the evil pirate captain who stole her innocence is none other than Justin Vallerand, her dead husband’s twin brother. Fortunately for her, he leaves immediately as there is a price on his head and he has a revenge to carryout. The Vallerand family accepts her with open arms and fattens her up. (I was so sure when she started complaining how all her dresses were too tight that she was preggers and we’d get our secret baby. But I was wrong. Biggest disappointment of the book.)
Four months later, Justin shows up at the plantation half dead. Despite her hatred, Celia nurses him back to life and, in the process, forges a bond with the difficult patient. When the authorities come sniffing around, the family passes Justin off as the dead brother, Philippe. Justin regains his strength and ravishes Celia some more, this time with her consent and cooperation.
The super eeevil pirate captain #1 shows up with the news that Philippe is alive!
Justin agrees to be traded in return for Philippe’s safety. Celia, in her one TSTL moment, follows to the trade point and is kidnapped. Justin and Celia and bad pirates return to secret pirate island. Justin’s crew springs escape. Battle! Fighting! Explosions! Mayhem! Good guys win and live Happily Ever After.
Discussion:
One can’t take this book seriously. I completely recommend it to die-hard romance fans, because you will be able to appreciate the silliness. Please do not give this book to your non-romance-reading friends. It is a Bodice Ripper.
Let’s start off with the cover. My cover has two swans on the front. There are no swans in the book. Swans, as far as I know, don’t even live in the carrebean or New Orleans or any other setting covered in the book. They are not mentioned anywhere in the book, nor is any character described as being swan-like. Why the cover? I. Have. No. Idea.
Secondly, the forced seduction. Y’all know how I feel about forced seductions. Why then did I not throw this book against a wall? This is the first book I’ve read where the rapist-hero actually goes through a believable character transformation over the course of the book. He is truly a different person who regrets his actions by the end of the book. He recognizes his vile acts and seeks to make amends. He is redeemed and gives his life in exchange for others. In addition, both the hero and the heroine realize that the forced seduction for what it is: BAD. The heroine hates the hero afterwards, and goes through her own transformation coming to terms with her rape, healing, and forgiving the hero.
This book would have been better with a baby epilogue. I was so sure the heroine was going to get knocked up. I was very disappointed when she didn’t. Not even in the epilogue! Come on Lisa – this book had everything but the baby! It’s my favorite cliche.
Irritating nicknames: the hero calls the heroine “infant,” which is so incredibly not sexy I can’t even begin to describe…grrrrrrr.
I recommend this book especially to all the Desert Island Ladies, because it’s set on a desert island, has lots of pirates and rum and fun.