TITLE: Twilight
AUTHOR: Stephanie Meyer
PUBLICATION: Little, Brown Children’s Books, September 2006
GENRE: Young Adult Paranormal Romance
RATING: <3 <3 <3
TWILIGHT is an international bestselling young adult book that fans claim is the next big thing since Harry Potter. The sheer amount of buzz turned me off. How could the book possibly live up to its hype? I finally gave in after a camping trip on the Olympic Peninsula, where the book is set. I didn’t want to be the last person on the planet to see what all the fuss was about. It was a daunting task, overcoming my preconceived notions, but Ms. Meyer’s debut novel in the end won me over. I quickly snapped up the remaining three books in the four book saga and was quite satisfied.
PLOT:
Isabella (Bella) Swan moves to Forks, a tiny town on the rainy Olympic Peninsula in Washington State, to live with her dad when her mother remarries. Bella braves being a new student in the small high school where everyone knows everyone else. Yay for small town life! To her surprise, every guy in school develops a crush on her, but she finds herself drawn to the mysterious and antisocial Cullen family. In particular, the youngest son Edward captures her attention, because he is the most beautiful person she has ever seen and he smells good. Edward and his siblings skip school when it is sunny and are never seen eating. They have cold skin and strange eyes. Edward is by turns charming and hostile. For him, she is the apple. He wants to take a bite. Despite his moodiness, Bella can’t get him out of her head. When he saves her life on more than one occasion, she becomes even more obsessed. (This relationship is unhealthy, which is why I am a Jacob fan-girl. Are we trying to tell our daughters that this behavior is normal? I hope not.)
Bella’s friend Jacob tells her some legends about bloodsuckers and shapeshifters, and Bella begins to put two and two together: The Cullens are not human. She confronts Edward and he relents into showing her some of his world of “vegetarian” vampires. He has difficulty not sucking her blood, but Edward is nothing if not self controlled. Unfortunately not all vampires are good, and when an evil vampire sets his sights on Bella, the Cullen family must band together to save her. Bella is very good at getting into life-endangering situations, and sitting around looking pretty while the men fight to save her.
DISCUSSION:

Twilight is TUCK EVERLASTING for the new generation. It’s a comment on our culture and society that the moral of the story has changed. In both we have a young female protagonist who is tempted by immortality when she meets a strange family that does not age and falls in love with the son. In Tuck Everlasting the apple of immortality is “a curse that disrupts the natural cycle of life.” In Twilight the dark side of immortality is…nonexistent? What happened to Eve being tempted by the apple resulting in the fall of mankind? The issue in Twilight is brought up, but never fully discussed. I think this would be a fascinating analytical essay, comparing the concepts of immortality and youth in the two novels.
The stated theme from Ms. Meyer’s is “there is always a choice,” that one’s nature does not condemn one to be evil. One can chose between right and wrong. I wonder though how Bella struggles with this theme. She doesn’t seem to have a choice about whom to love – it is almost fated. The Cullen’s choose not to be human-killers. What else?
TWILIGHT is a gateway book. It is, in essence, a vampire romance. I’ve read tons of vampire romances, and compared to the genre as a whole, Twilight has serious competition. For romance newbies, Twilight is a perfect place to start a serious love affair with romance novels. (Which is of course my evil plan, to addict as many people as possible. Mwuhahahaha.) The romance is light and chaste (it’s a YA after all) and the paranormal aspects aren’t too dark. Bella’s high school experiences – adapting to a new school, the horrors of gym class, teenage angst – play quite a large role. Personally, I dislike reliving high school. Once was enough.
The characters are the highlight of the book, the reason this series has touched so many hearts. Bella, for all her perfection, is human; shy and awkward, but most importantly kind. We would all like to be friends with her. Edward, of course, is gorgeous. Who wouldn’t want to be Bella, to be adored by everyone? She is Helen of Troy, Paris’ golden apple, inspiring madness wherever she goes. Somehow this doesn’t go to her head; she is selfless. A martyr.
Ms. Meyer’s style and pacing pick up in the second book, but in her debut the reader follows Bella on a lot of day-to-day activities – waking up, brushing her teeth, eating breakfast, etc. For a reader who is used to fast-paced vampire romance, this can be a turn off. Keep reading. By the end of the book you’ll be invested with the characters.
I recommend this book, with some caveats. Mostly, I don’t think that Bella is a healthy role model for teenage girls. It must be terrible to write YA and have people telling you that your heroes and heroines must be role-models. What happened to simply telling a good story? But thems the breaks. Bella and Edward share something much closer to obsession than love. Over the course of the Saga it improved, but in the first two books it was unhealthy.
EDITED TO ADD: Smart Bitch Sarah hits the nail on the head with her exposé on Edward as an Old-Skool Romance Hero. This is why I’m on Team Jacob. I despise Old-Skool romances.
I can’t wait for the movie: NOVEMBER 21, 2008!
PS: It’s TWILIGHT SAGA week.
Monday – Twilight
Tuesday – New Moon
Wednesday – Eclipse
Thursday – Book Recommendations for people who loved Twilight
Friday – Breaking Dawn